Writing on the wall: Why Pasifika rugby is in trouble

June 28, 2026 • Web Admin •
Share this story:
Writing on the wall: Why Pasifika rugby is in trouble

FOR rugby union fans in Samoa, Tonga and other Pacific Islands, the news that Moana Pasifika will be disbanded at the end of the 2026 season would have come as a big disappointment.

It is important for rugby union fans to examine the root causes of the failure of Moana Pasifika in the Pacific Super Rugby competition.

Some of the lessons might also constitute writing on the wall for the Fijian Drua. But can there be opportunities arising out of this adversity going into the future?

Especially if we keep an open mind about which “brand of rugby” might be most “beneficial” for sports persons in the Pacific in the long run.

The three rugby brands

Let us leave aside soccer in which the only players allowed to handle the ball are the goalkeepers. The other three (AFL, NRL and Rugby Union) all allow players to handle the ball but have completely different rules of operation and scoring, geographical location and degree of fan followership.

AFL or Australian Rules Football has its origins in Victoria and today has teams from all over Australia. NFL (National Football League) originated in NSW and now has teams from all over Australia and NZ.

Rugby Union originated in Britain but spread to Australia, NZ and South Africa. Pacific Super Rugby has teams from Australia, NZ and the Pacific.

Different degrees of popularity

There is little doubt about the immense popularity of AFL, which will regularly draw crowds in excess of 80,000 at the MCG in Melbourne. The games are usually broadcast free to air.

NFL, on the other hand, is similarly extremely popular, regularly filling stadiums where they play while most games are free to air.

In contrast, it is clear that rugby union games have great difficulty in filling stadiums: most games are very poorly attended, while they are not broadcast free to air.

Any ordinary television viewer will immediately understand one possible factor in the demise of Moana Pasifika: the relative lack of paying customers for rugby union.

With rugby union raising much lower gate takings and advertising revenue than the other two rugby brands, it is not surprising that the team lowest in the league tables (Moana Pasifika) will have difficulty surviving financially.

If the relative decline of rugby union vis a vis AFL and NRL continues into the future (as is likely), the demise of Moana Pasifika may be “writing on the wall” for the Fijian Drua.

Pacific origins of players

There are very few Pacific Islanders playing AFL. Most Pacific Islanders have opted for rugby union, largely because of the historical colonial popularity of this brand in Fiji, Samoa, Tonga and Cook Islands.

It was not surprising therefore that there was a Fijian Drua team based in Fiji, as well as Moana Pasifika based in NZ but drawing on Pacific Islanders, mostly Samoa and Tonga.

It is extremely encouraging, however, that there are more and more Pacific Islanders playing and starring in the NRL competition even though there is no NRL competition in the Pacific Islands.

I suspect that the salaries of the Pacific Islanders in the NRL Teams are far superior to the salaries of the Pacific Islanders in the Super Rugby competition.

Which brand for Pacific rugby?

Pacific Island countries wishing to foster sport in their own countries and populations, of course cannot disregard the love of their people for particular brands of rugby. We in the Pacific have absolutely adored rugby union.

I personally prefer to watch rugby union with exciting free flowing possibilities at every move with competitive lineouts and scrums, rather than NRL, which I consider relatively monotonous. But it is the fans’ views that matter, through their pockets. Not the views of armchair critics.

But those with an eye to the future must take account of the historical origins of the various brands and the future directions they are taking currently, fully considering the financial and geostrategic aspects.

For Pacific countries, the AFL does not hold any future prospects, not the least because the grounds required are much larger than those required for rugby union and NRL. So, the choice is therefore between rugby union and NRL.

I have alluded to the clear commercial popularity of NRL in Australia, over rugby union. But in the last year, there has been an astonishing Australian Government initiative for NRL in PNG which Pacific Islanders cannot ignore.

PNG NRL and sports diplomacy

Just last year, the Australian Government (PM Albanese) announced a $AUD600 million package to initiate a PNG NRL Team based in Port Moresby and debuting in 2028 in the NRL competition in Australia/NZ.

This deal attracted the attention of political commentators in Australia as highlighted in The Conversation. Part of the deal supposedly was that “PNG will not sign a security deal that could allow Chinese police or military forces to be based in the Pacific nation”.

The Conversation noted that “other possible negatives: perceptions that this is just neocolonial Australia bullying, patronising, poaching talent, demonising China, militarising the Pacific (via AUKUS), and even sportswashing – that is, co-opting rugby league to deflect attention from other issues”.

Be that as it may, what lesson does it have for rugby in the Pacific?

What lesson for the Pacific?

For Pacific Islanders, the Australian Government’s support of PNG NRL has a powerful lesson here: rugby is not just all about healthy sports for Pacific Islanders.

Sports administrators must also consider that the superpowers of the region (i.e., Australia and NZ) are now viewing sports as a powerful force binding our peoples together, against perceived external threats.

So which brand of rugby should our countries foster: rugby union or NRL?

Even Australian and NZ rugby unions have recognised, especially after COVID, that there are commercial drawbacks to maintaining sporting links with Britain, France, South Africa, and Argentina.

Their Super Rugby therefore contracted to the Pacific.

Unfortunately, the Moana Pasifika could not survive financially in the limited competition. There is very little chance that they can make it back.

If the declining trends for rugby union continue, it is possible that even the Fijian Drua teams (both men and women) may end up struggling in the future.

Here is a tough decision for rugby union administrators in the Pacific to make for the benefit of sports players and fans
in the Pacific.

Switch emphasis to NRL?

The Governments of Samoa and Tonga (and Fiji) might wish to consider a drastic policy shift: switch support to a Pasifika NRL Team playing in the Australia/NZ NRL competition, alongside the PNG Team.

I am sure that just as the Australian Government provided a substantial financial package to assist the PNG NRL Team, it would also not be averse to providing one for the Pasifika NRL Team whose base can rotate between Samoa and Tonga (and perhaps Fiji).

What is a virtual certainty, is that there will be far more Pacific Island players in the NRL competition, playing for all the Teams and not just their own, than currently.

Nearly all will be sending part of their earnings home to their families, strengthening the remittance earnings of Tonga, Samoa and Fiji way above their already record levels.

All the more reason for their governments to think long and hard about switching their national support from rugby union teams to NRL teams and competitions, in their respective countries.

For economists, the choice is obvious.

Writing on the wall: Why Pasifika rugby is in trouble

June 28, 2026 • Web Admin •
Share this story:
Writing on the wall: Why Pasifika rugby is in trouble

FOR rugby union fans in Samoa, Tonga and other Pacific Islands, the news that Moana Pasifika will be disbanded at the end of the 2026 season would have come as a big disappointment.

It is important for rugby union fans to examine the root causes of the failure of Moana Pasifika in the Pacific Super Rugby competition.

Some of the lessons might also constitute writing on the wall for the Fijian Drua. But can there be opportunities arising out of this adversity going into the future?

Especially if we keep an open mind about which “brand of rugby” might be most “beneficial” for sports persons in the Pacific in the long run.

The three rugby brands

Let us leave aside soccer in which the only players allowed to handle the ball are the goalkeepers. The other three (AFL, NRL and Rugby Union) all allow players to handle the ball but have completely different rules of operation and scoring, geographical location and degree of fan followership.

AFL or Australian Rules Football has its origins in Victoria and today has teams from all over Australia. NFL (National Football League) originated in NSW and now has teams from all over Australia and NZ.

Rugby Union originated in Britain but spread to Australia, NZ and South Africa. Pacific Super Rugby has teams from Australia, NZ and the Pacific.

Different degrees of popularity

There is little doubt about the immense popularity of AFL, which will regularly draw crowds in excess of 80,000 at the MCG in Melbourne. The games are usually broadcast free to air.

NFL, on the other hand, is similarly extremely popular, regularly filling stadiums where they play while most games are free to air.

In contrast, it is clear that rugby union games have great difficulty in filling stadiums: most games are very poorly attended, while they are not broadcast free to air.

Any ordinary television viewer will immediately understand one possible factor in the demise of Moana Pasifika: the relative lack of paying customers for rugby union.

With rugby union raising much lower gate takings and advertising revenue than the other two rugby brands, it is not surprising that the team lowest in the league tables (Moana Pasifika) will have difficulty surviving financially.

If the relative decline of rugby union vis a vis AFL and NRL continues into the future (as is likely), the demise of Moana Pasifika may be “writing on the wall” for the Fijian Drua.

Pacific origins of players

There are very few Pacific Islanders playing AFL. Most Pacific Islanders have opted for rugby union, largely because of the historical colonial popularity of this brand in Fiji, Samoa, Tonga and Cook Islands.

It was not surprising therefore that there was a Fijian Drua team based in Fiji, as well as Moana Pasifika based in NZ but drawing on Pacific Islanders, mostly Samoa and Tonga.

It is extremely encouraging, however, that there are more and more Pacific Islanders playing and starring in the NRL competition even though there is no NRL competition in the Pacific Islands.

I suspect that the salaries of the Pacific Islanders in the NRL Teams are far superior to the salaries of the Pacific Islanders in the Super Rugby competition.

Which brand for Pacific rugby?

Pacific Island countries wishing to foster sport in their own countries and populations, of course cannot disregard the love of their people for particular brands of rugby. We in the Pacific have absolutely adored rugby union.

I personally prefer to watch rugby union with exciting free flowing possibilities at every move with competitive lineouts and scrums, rather than NRL, which I consider relatively monotonous. But it is the fans’ views that matter, through their pockets. Not the views of armchair critics.

But those with an eye to the future must take account of the historical origins of the various brands and the future directions they are taking currently, fully considering the financial and geostrategic aspects.

For Pacific countries, the AFL does not hold any future prospects, not the least because the grounds required are much larger than those required for rugby union and NRL. So, the choice is therefore between rugby union and NRL.

I have alluded to the clear commercial popularity of NRL in Australia, over rugby union. But in the last year, there has been an astonishing Australian Government initiative for NRL in PNG which Pacific Islanders cannot ignore.

PNG NRL and sports diplomacy

Just last year, the Australian Government (PM Albanese) announced a $AUD600 million package to initiate a PNG NRL Team based in Port Moresby and debuting in 2028 in the NRL competition in Australia/NZ.

This deal attracted the attention of political commentators in Australia as highlighted in The Conversation. Part of the deal supposedly was that “PNG will not sign a security deal that could allow Chinese police or military forces to be based in the Pacific nation”.

The Conversation noted that “other possible negatives: perceptions that this is just neocolonial Australia bullying, patronising, poaching talent, demonising China, militarising the Pacific (via AUKUS), and even sportswashing – that is, co-opting rugby league to deflect attention from other issues”.

Be that as it may, what lesson does it have for rugby in the Pacific?

What lesson for the Pacific?

For Pacific Islanders, the Australian Government’s support of PNG NRL has a powerful lesson here: rugby is not just all about healthy sports for Pacific Islanders.

Sports administrators must also consider that the superpowers of the region (i.e., Australia and NZ) are now viewing sports as a powerful force binding our peoples together, against perceived external threats.

So which brand of rugby should our countries foster: rugby union or NRL?

Even Australian and NZ rugby unions have recognised, especially after COVID, that there are commercial drawbacks to maintaining sporting links with Britain, France, South Africa, and Argentina.

Their Super Rugby therefore contracted to the Pacific.

Unfortunately, the Moana Pasifika could not survive financially in the limited competition. There is very little chance that they can make it back.

If the declining trends for rugby union continue, it is possible that even the Fijian Drua teams (both men and women) may end up struggling in the future.

Here is a tough decision for rugby union administrators in the Pacific to make for the benefit of sports players and fans
in the Pacific.

Switch emphasis to NRL?

The Governments of Samoa and Tonga (and Fiji) might wish to consider a drastic policy shift: switch support to a Pasifika NRL Team playing in the Australia/NZ NRL competition, alongside the PNG Team.

I am sure that just as the Australian Government provided a substantial financial package to assist the PNG NRL Team, it would also not be averse to providing one for the Pasifika NRL Team whose base can rotate between Samoa and Tonga (and perhaps Fiji).

What is a virtual certainty, is that there will be far more Pacific Island players in the NRL competition, playing for all the Teams and not just their own, than currently.

Nearly all will be sending part of their earnings home to their families, strengthening the remittance earnings of Tonga, Samoa and Fiji way above their already record levels.

All the more reason for their governments to think long and hard about switching their national support from rugby union teams to NRL teams and competitions, in their respective countries.

For economists, the choice is obvious.