WE have strategies, declarations, roadmaps, action plans, development plans and regional commitments. Many of them are thoughtful, ambitious, and grounded in true concern for the future of our region.
The 2050 Strategy for the Blue Pacific Continent is one of the clear current examples, integrating political leadership and regionalism, people-centred development, peace and security, climate change, ocean and environment, resources and economic development, and technology and connectivity.
Today, we ought to ask ourselves, whether the systems expected to carry these frameworks can actually work together. This is indeed vital, because Pacific life does not materialise in sectors. For instance, a family facing the impacts of climate change is not experiencing a climate issue on Monday, an economic issue on Tuesday, and a health issue on Wednesday.
The same family may be dealing all at once with mounting food costs, damaged land, changing weather patterns, migration decisions, housing pressures, health concerns, education, cultural responsibilities and worries regarding the future of their children. In other words, their reality is interconnected.
However, when we look very closely into the institutions that are responding to that reality, they are often divided into separate departments programmes, funding streams, reporting requirements, and professional disciplines. This is where some of our difficulty lies.
Moving the planning to holding things together
This is not a new problem. Pacific governments, regional organisations and development partners have long grappled with coordination, duplication and the gap between policy and implementation.
What makes the present moment crucial is that the region itself is gradually acknowledging that implementation must now become the priority. The 2050 Strategy has moved the talanoa from just imagining where the Blue Pacific should be by 2050, towards how national priorities, regional ambitions, evidence, resources and development partnerships work together.
But alignment should mean more than placing different plans beneath the same regional strategy. That means that it should also make us ask whether the relationships between our systems are working.
For example, a programme can meet its targets and still fail to strengthen a community. An organisation can complete all its reporting requirements while the people it serves experience little lasting change. Several agencies can work on the same problem and each perform well according to its own measures, while the overall system remains fragmented.
Sometimes, every part can be working, but the whole is not. This is the bigger challenge.
Compartmentalisation is not our thing in the Pacific
One of the strengths of Pacific societies is that we have never understood life in its fullness in separate compartments. Our families, communities, spirituality, land, ocean, identity, genealogy, leadership and obligations to one another overlap.
They are neither always easy relationships, nor should we romanticise them. Yet, interconnectedness remains fundamental to how many Pacific communities understand themselves.
That raises an important question: Why should Pacific development continue to be organised predominantly through systems that separate realities our communities experience together? My own work has led me frequently to the Tongan concept of Felupe. At its simplest, I use Felupe to describe the carrying or holding of things together. I developed this thinking more fully through my research into Pacific climate resilience, but its significance reaches beyond climate change.
For me, Felupe is not another framework that needs to be placed beside all the frameworks we already have. It is a way of asking a different question: What is holding everything together? When we design a policy, what connects it to the community expected to live with its consequences? When development funding arrives, what connects the priorities of the funder with those of the people? When researchers collect evidence, what connects that knowledge back to those who shared it? When government agencies, NGOs, churches, businesses, traditional leaders and communities address the same problem, what holds their different contributions together?
These questions take us beyond coordination meetings. They are questions about relationships, power, accountability and coherence.
Another framework will not solve fragmentation
There is always a temptation when something is not working to design something new. The usual reaction is to come up with a new strategy, model, programme, committee, set of indicators and so on. Sometimes, these are necessary. However, sometimes, the problem is not the absence of another structure. The problem is that what already exists has not been connected well enough.
Before creating something new, perhaps we should ask what already exists, what is working, what is disconnected, whose voices are missing and where relationships have weakened. Our measures of success may need some attention as well.
Of course we are good at counting activities, workshops, participants, outputs and expenditure and these things matter. At the same time, we should become equally serious about asking whether trust has increased, whether communities have greater capability, whether relationships between institutions have strengthened, whether knowledge moves in both directions, and whether people have greater influence over decisions affecting their lives.
Those things are harder to put into a spreadsheet. They may also tell us more about whether transformation is actually occurring.
The next Pacific innovation may be connection
The Pacific certainly needs innovation. Climate change, demographic pressures, economic vulnerability, geopolitical competition and technological change will demand new thinking.
But innovation does not always mean inventing something that did not exist yesterday. Sometimes, innovation is discovering how to connect what has been separated.
The 2050 Strategy gives the region a shared direction. The challenge now is not just to add more commitments beneath it, but also to make the relationships between national priorities, regional institutions, development partners and Pacific communities’ work.
The future of Pacific regionalism may therefore depend less on how many new frameworks we can produce and more on whether we can learn to hold our existing knowledge, institutions, resources and relationships together.
We have done a great deal of planning and need to be acknowledged and appreciated. Yet it’s time that we move from planning and ask ourselves: What will Litia hold it together?