SOMEWHERE between the ocean and our plates, the men who make the global seafood industry possible work the vessels. And during the days, weeks and months of their travail, some of them disappear. But because these workers are invisible, who would know – or that they ever existed. But wait! There is a list.
In the island state of Fiji, there is a list that now contains page after page, name after name, unknown after unknown, of the disappeared. It records crew members, fisheries observers and captains who have died, disappeared or mysteriously never returned from tuna fishing vessels operating across the Pacific or further afield. Those were men who simply vanished from public attention (if they ever had any), becoming another forgotten casualty of an industry that feeds millions but remains largely hidden from public view, and is unaccountable to those who depend on it for work and the families left stranded awaiting an explanation of
disappearance.
If one spends any meaningful amount of time in Suva, the capital of Fiji, they will likely cross paths with Dr Patricia Kailola, Executive Officer of Human Dignity Group and a fisheries scientist who has spent years documenting these disappearances. A passionate advocate against human trafficking, she calls it her list of dead and missing, cognisant that while we often see tuna neatly stacked in cans on supermarket shelves, served in restaurants or exported around the world, there is barely an inkling among the general public regarding the emergency facing the people who make that all possible.
For many Fijians and other Pacific Islanders, fishing offers one of the few reliable sources of income. In coastal and rural communities, where employment opportunities are limited, going to sea is a potentially lucrative way of providing for parents, spouses and children.
For too many, however, that promise comes at an enormous cost. In the Suva–Nausori area alone, it is estimated that at least 250 men have worked, or continue to work, as deckhands on Fiji’s longline fishing vessels, performing the physically demanding work on which the industry depends: setting the lines, hauling, cleaning, gutting and storing fish to maintain its quality before it reaches international markets.
Yet many men report being recruited without written contracts, leaving them with little protection. They describe working between 16 to 22 hours a day, seven days a week, for months at a time. Crew members speak of poor-quality meals (“pieces of cucumber and onion in boiled water”), dirty drinking water (“sometimes from the air-conditioning system of the vessel”), bug-infested mattresses, rats and very limited access to health care.
When their vessel finally returns to port, many crew members first unload the catch before receiving their wages; wages that, according to some accounts, have been subject to unexplained deductions. Some men also report they are required to pay for their raincoats, boots and protective clothing despite Fiji’s ‘health at work’ laws requiring employers to provide such equipment free of charge.
These statements are not only the reflection of poor working conditions. They are stark reminders that, once a vessel leaves port, the protections many workers take for granted on land can become far more difficult to guarantee. When abuses occur hundreds or even thousands of kilometres from shore, accountability becomes blurred.
Which country’s laws apply? Who investigates? Who ensures that labour standards are respected? Who speaks for workers when they cannot speak for themselves? Too often, the answer appears to be ‘no one.’
Fiji has the potential to become a global leader in responsible fisheries. It is already recognised internationally for the quality of its tuna and its commitment to sustainable fisheries management. It could also become known for setting the highest standards for protecting the people whose labour underpins the industry.
Consumers increasingly ask where their coffee comes from, whether their clothes were made ethically and whether the products they buy were produced responsibly. Seafood should be no different.
The people catching the fish that feed the world deserve the same rights as every other worker: fair wages, safe working conditions, adequate food and clean water, access to health care, and the dignity that comes with being treated as human beings rather than as a disposable part of a supply chain.
These rights should not disappear the moment a vessel leaves harbour. Kailola’s list is more than a record of the dead and missing. It brings into the open a tragedy that remains largely invisible. Every new entry represents a family searching for answers. Every disappearance raises questions that deserve investigation.
Every unexplained death should concern governments, industry leaders and consumers alike. The first step is to make these stories visible. The next is to ensure they can no longer be ignored. The measure of a successful fishing industry should not be the volume of fish it lands or the profits it generates alone. It should also be measured by how it treats the people whose labour keeps it afloat.
Perhaps, with this, the most important question is no longer how many names are on Kailola’s list. It is why, after hundreds of names, we still allow the list to grow.