For 15 years, the Kingdom of Tonga has gone through a political experiment that was supposed to make the governance system “more democratic”. This was the declared will of the former Monarch, King George Tupou V, the chief architect of the Constitutional Reform of 2010.
But the events of the past 12 months have threatened to undo the attempt to make Tonga more democratic. King Tupou VI seems to be reasserting his royal will in the appointment, as well as in the running of government.
With a new Prime Minister elected by Parliament, the country awaits the appointment of a replacement Cabinet. The month-long delay has been due to the fact that King Tupou VI may still be going over the list of appointees from the Prime Minister, to see if they are suitable.
This has never been done before in all the administrations after the 2010 Reform. The Parliament elects the Prime Minister, who in turn appoints Cabinet. The King’s approval is a matter of formality and ensures a check and balance of power. There have been four Prime Ministers with their respective governments since 2010. The current Prime Minister would be the fifth.
Prior to the 2010 Reform, the King appointed the Prime Minister and every Minister in the Cabinet. The key change in the reform was that the Parliament elects the Prime Minister, and the Prime Minister appoints all the members of his Cabinet.
Are we going to see a new trend in Tonga’s pathway to becoming “more democratic”? Is the Monarch going to reassert more of his power to influence the appointment of government? Are we taking steps backwards from the essence of the 2010 Reform? Or is this part of moving forward?
Tonga’s fragile and struggling democracy is at a crossroads of sorts. At the heart of the current difficulties are two offices of power that may be pulling two different directions at the expense of what’s good for the nation.
A vote of no confidence and a resignation
A vote of no confidence (VONC) motion in the former Prime Minister, Hu’akavameiiku Siaosi Sovaleni, was lodged in Parliament in November 2024. There was one earlier in his administration in 2023, but it was defeated. The second VONC was about to be tabled in Parliament when Sovaleni pre-empted it by resigning, just before Christmas.
Sovaleni’s teary speech in his resignation was indicative of the fact that he had felt pressured to do or be something he was not in agreement with. There had been ongoing tension between him and the Monarch, King Tupou VI.
“I thought this land had been granted freedom, but there’s still enslavement,” he said. He was quitting “for the good of the country and moving Tonga forward”. He also referred to the nobles as being afraid and so were swayed from standing with him. Three of the nobles who were in his government resigned and voted for the opposition that was led by current Prime Minister Dr ‘Aisake Eke.
Addressing the people’s representatives, he said: “If the nobles can pull themselves together, I don’t know why we can’t overcome our differences.” And referring to the nobles, he added: “I hope there will be
a time when we’ll work together.”
It was on 4 February 2024 that a letter was received by the Prime Minister through the Privy Council, an advisory body to the King. The letter says that His Majesty “had withdrawn his confidence and consent to the appointment of Hon. Huakavameiliku as the Minister of His Majesty’s Armed Forces… and also to the appointment of Hon. Fekitamoeloa ‘Utoikamanu as the Minister of Foreign Affairs and as Minister for Tourism.”
Both former Prime Minister Sovaleni and ‘Utoikamanu resigned from their portfolios to appease the King, but tension had prevailed in the relationship between the Palace Office and the Prime Minister’s Office.
The King would have to be involved in the appointment of new ministers of Defence and Foreign Affairs. The Crown Prince, Tupouto’a ‘Ulukalala, is believed to be on the list of Cabinet Ministers as Minister of Defence and Foreign Affairs.
He is not an elected member of Parliament. Is this going to be a new normal?
The long delay of one month without the appointment of a new Cabinet seems to give signals that every single Minister appointed by the Prime Minister, as his constitutional right, would now need to have full approval from the King.
The delay in Cabinet appointments, now scheduled to be announced on January 31, means that the new Prime Minister and Ministers will only have nine months in government. They will be operating within the former government’s budget until the end of June, and then from first of July, they will need to come up with a new budget to be in operation for four months before parliament goes into recess for the general election.
Sovaleni, Eke, and King Tupou VI
To be fair to the former Prime Minister, he had one of the most effective administrations in the development of Tonga, despite the criticism against him. He outperformed all previous administrations in completing major development projects for Tonga. He also successfully hosted the Pacific Islands Forum, the most significant regional leaders conference ever held in Tonga.
Sovaleni was also quite effective in establishing relationships with other nations, winning their trust to give aid to Tonga, and even to be the base for the multi-million-dollar Pacific Resilience Fund.
Dr Eke and his government will only have a few months to try and match anything the previous government achieved. They obviously hope to continue to govern after the November election.
There’s one thing for sure, Eke’s government will have more royal support than Sovaleni’s.
King Tupou VI will obviously be playing a more active role in government than any Monarch after the 2010 Reform.
Kalafi Moala is a journalist, media owner, and author. He is a respected commentator on Tongan politics.