Bad behaviour: The need for regional cooperation

August 30, 2025 • Web Admin •
Share this story:
Bad behaviour: The need for regional cooperation

Mid-last year, reports started surfacing that Deep Sea Mining Finance (DSMF) was extracting seabed minerals in Papua New Guinea’s (PNG) exclusive economic zone (EEZ), unbeknownst to government and without permission from local communities.

This incident is just one among a growing list of dubious seabed activities taking place in the Pacific, each of which reveal the danger this sector poses to Pacific institutions, principles and finances if left unchecked.

A collective approach may be the Pacific’s strongest defence against such harm, and critical for preventing nations being pitted against one another in a race to the bottom for deep-sea riches.

Bad behaviour
With seabed minerals activities often conducted far offshore and at depths that defy easy observation, the effective governance of this sector is a major challenge. Earlier mentioned reports of DSMF’s extraction of seabed minerals in PNG without the knowledge, let alone approval, of government exposes the bad faith with which some contractors are engaging with Pacific authorities. So severe was DSMF’s apparent breach of national frameworks that former PNG Prime Minister and New Ireland Governor, the late Julius Chan, described its activities as “illegal”.

These reports of bad behaviour are not solely an issue for PNG. DSMF also holds seabed exploration rights in Tonga’s EEZ, raising questions about its conduct in other Pacific jurisdictions. This example of alleged contractor non-compliance highlights the need for greater information sharing and coordinated management of contractor activities across the region. It is imperative that acts of bad faith (if not bad
actors) are addressed early and consistently to prevent their spread among other jurisdictions.

Incompatible principles
The international system has been a key vehicle through which Pacific communities have exercised influence and authority on the global stage. From the region’s advocacy of an expansive EEZ regime in Law of the Sea negotiations, to its push for a global driftnet ban and submission to the International Court of Justice on the obligations of states in respect of climate change, Pacific nations have contributed
and (in many cases) benefitted from a global rules-based order. This is reflected in regional statements, including the Boe Declaration in 2018 and Pacific Islands Forum Leaders Ocean Statement of 2021.

Such regard for international law, however, cannot be said of one of the leading seabed minerals contractors active in the Pacific region: The Metals Company (TMC). In April this year, TMC submitted an application to mine the international seabed under an old US law, the Deep Seabed Hard Mineral Resources Act, rather than through the global seabed regulator, the International Seabed Authority (ISA). As Leticia Carvalho, Secretary-General of the ISA, notes, this move fundamentally undercuts international law, seeking to bypass global processes, community, and oversight to mine the international seabed under the authority of one nation.

TMC’s flouting of international seabed governance flies against the Pacific’s longstanding support for a global rules-based order. It raises questions about this contractor’s respect for shared Pacific principles and its willingness to comply with relevant governing frameworks.


Costly penalties
In 2011, the PNG Government granted a 20-year mining license to seabed minerals contractor Nautilus for the Solwara 1 project. With this licence, the government also negotiated ‘full equity participation’ where it committed to acquiring a 30% share in Solwara 1 over a three- to four-year period.

Eighteen months later, however, the PNG Government accused Nautilus of having failed to meet the obligations set out under the Agreement and announced it would terminate its full equity participation. Nautilus challenged the government’s decision through the international system, filing a notice for arbitration under the UN Commission on International Trade Law. This arbitration ultimately ruled in
favour of Nautilus, with the PNG Government compelled to maintain its investment in the project (which was eventually renegotiated to a 15% share).

When Nautilus was liquidated in 2019 (before any seabed mining activities occurred), the PNG Government’s investment was lost with it. This not only put the PNG Government $USD120 million out of pocket, but also outstanding in the loan it held with the Bank of the South Pacific (BSP). In short, the PNG Government’s change of mind proved extremely costly – financially and politically. Attempts to alter
the terms of its seabed minerals engagement were met with fierce backlash from private contractors, which, in effect, challenged the political authority of the government over activities within its own jurisdiction.

This case is not isolated. Last year, Odyssey Marine Exploration successfully sued the Mexican Government through an international arbitration process, after the government repeatedly denied environmental permits for Odyssey’s seabed phosphates project. Of note for the Pacific: Odyssey also has interests in seabed activities within the region, holding shares in CIC Ltd and Moana Minerals, which
have exploration licences in the Cook Islands.

These cases indicate the power that private seabed contractors have leveraged over countries who seek to renegotiate the terms of their engagement in seabed minerals activities. While Pacific governments may hold different positions on this sector (some considering future mining while others calling for a moratorium), this shouldn’t diminish their shared commitment to the authority of Pacific states over
seabed activities in their own waters.

Where to from here?
Safeguarding Pacific sovereignty will be critical as the sector continues to evolve. It is for this reason that regional cooperation on seabed minerals is necessary: building on long legacies of Pacific solidarity and assertions of collective power (e.g., Parties to the Nauru Agreement, Pacific Islands Producers Association).
While technical and scientific cooperation on seabed minerals has a long history in the Pacific (e.g., SOPAC), examples of political cooperation have been few and far between. This is despite calls from Pacific visionaries, including Sir Mekere Morauta, Vice Chancellor Transform Aqorau, Maurice Brownjohn, as well as legal expert Hannah Lily.

Cases of contractor misconduct highlight the urgent need for regional cooperation, and the assertion of what Pacific communities will and will not accept within their Blue Pacific seabed. This could be pursued through a regional statement on Principles for Pacific Seabed Stewardship or the introduction of harmonised minimum terms and conditions for seabed activities.

Collective solidarity has proven effective in guarding against ‘divide and conquer’ predation in the past. It may hold the key to safeguarding the Pacific seabed—and Pacific sovereignty— into the future.