Labour mobility: Double-edged sword

December 16, 2025 • Web Admin •
Share this story:
Labour mobility: Double-edged sword
Pick of the crop ... Pacific seasonal workers in New Zealand. Blessing or curse? Photo: Pick Hawke's Bay

LABOUR mobility in the Pacific has reached a significant scale, with seasonal schemes driving the most recent migration flows.

By mid-2023, approximately 116,000 Pacific people had participated in New Zealand’s Recognised Seasonal Employer (RSE) scheme and Australia’s short-term Pacific Australia Labour Mobility (PALM) scheme.

“This number matches the total documented Pacific labour migration during the 50 years of the blackbirding era (1861–1911), showing historic continuity in scale,” said Emeritus Professor Richard Bedford at the University of Waikato and the Auckland University of Technology during the DevNet 2025 Symposium on Pacific Labour Mobility.

“Vanuatu accounts for over 60% of these seasonal workers, maintaining its historical dominance in labour migration to Australia and New Zealand,” he said.

Australia’s seasonal scheme began in 2012 and expanded in 2019 with a three-year visa, merging into the broader PALM scheme by 2021, marking a major policy shift in Australian immigration.

“This shift signals a significant change from the restrictive 1901 Pacific Island Labourers Act, which had limited Pacific migration to Australia for over a century,” he added.

As of March 2024, approximately 44,000 workers were onshore in Australia and New Zealand across major labour schemes.

16,000 workers were on the long-term PALM scheme, 14,600 on the short-term PALM scheme, and 13,400 on New Zealand’s RSE scheme.

Bedford said the long-term PALM scheme now accommodates slightly more workers than the short-term scheme because of visa durations of three to four years.

“Different countries show varied participation patterns, with Vanuatu mostly in seasonal schemes, while Fiji and Solomon Islands have more workers on long-term schemes.

“Australia’s schemes have overtaken New Zealand’s RSE in participation numbers for most Pacific countries except Samoa.”

Labour mobility’s impact on local male labour forces is substantial, with some countries temporarily losing up to a quarter of their working-age men overseas for work.

“In March 2025, Tonga had nearly 25% of its males aged 20–59 absent on seasonal visas in Australia and New Zealand.

“Vanuatu, Tuvalu, and Samoa also showed high percentages of male labour force absent offshore.

He added that larger countries like Papua New Guinea and Fiji have smaller relative shares despite their population sizes.

“Over 18 years, nearly 40% of Tongan males aged 20–59 have worked on New Zealand’s RSE scheme, demonstrating deep penetration of labour mobility in some communities.

“A recent pilot study showed intra-Pacific labour mobility can address local labour shortages, exemplified by Solomon Islands workers filling aged care roles in Niue.

“Niue’s ageing population and labour shortages create demand for skilled workers from younger populations like Solomon Islands.

“This model aligns with demographic differences across Pacific nations, where some have youthful populations while others have ageing workforces.”

Policy shifts and strategic implications

Recent policy changes have transformed Pacific labour mobility, creating both opportunities and challenges for source countries.

Australia’s introduction and rapid expansion of the PALM schemes since 2012 mark a historic shift in immigration policy.

This change ended decades of restrictive policies and opened new pathways for Pacific workers in Australia.

The 2019 addition of a three-year visa and the 2021 scheme merger demonstrate the government’s commitment to long-term labour mobility.

This policy change boosts Australia’s capacity to meet labour needs in primary industries and beyond, while providing economic opportunities for Pacific communities.

According to Bedford, the Pacific governments are increasingly aware and concerned about labour mobility in domestic labour markets.

“High percentages of working-age males absent offshore raise fears of labour shortages in key local industries.

“Some countries are beginning to monitor and potentially regulate flows to balance economic benefits with domestic labour needs.

“Tonga and Vanuatu are particularly cautious due to the scale of male labour absence,” he said.

Data and research needs 

Data transparency and availability remain critical issues for managing labour mobility effectively.

He added that gaps in census data, especially birthplace details, limit understanding of intra-regional movements.

“Improved data sharing and publication are necessary for policymakers and researchers to track trends and impacts accurately.

“The PACER Plus Implementation Unit’s open meetings and data collection efforts help fill some of these gaps.

“Understanding labour mobility’s full impact requires continuous study, better data, and nuanced regional strategies,” he said. 

Labour mobility should be viewed as part of broader demographic and economic transformations in the Pacific.

“Population structures vary widely, offering unique opportunities for labour exchanges that match age and skill profiles.

“Future policies should integrate demographic forecasts to optimise mobility benefits for both sending and receiving countries.”