Policy of silence

July 21, 2026 • Web Admin •
Share this story:
Policy of silence

THE Fiji Police Force wellbeing policy is in place. The language is in place.

The annual reports are in place. But the lived experience far exceeds what is in place, which raises questions about the gap between awareness and reality. Ramacake and Lawakeli said their study highlighted 68 per cent of officers knew a wellbeing policy existed.

However, it is still concerning that two-thirds felt wellbeing was “never prioritised” in the Force, and 55 per cent never sought help despite 92 per cent reporting potentially traumatic incidents.

“The gap is between awareness of policy and actual, felt organisational support; meaning that the policy exists on paper but isn’t experienced as real or accessible,” the authors said.

Another gap is the Fiji Police Force’s inconsistent effort to embed a professional debriefing system across all functional units – one that identifies, reviews, monitors, and refers cases to internal or external professionals who provide ongoing supervision support to its workforce.

“This may include getting an expert on board to offer support and undertaking a train-the-trainers upskilling programme.”

The authors are blunt about where the system breaks down: “60 per cent of officers said stigma definitely existed.”

“The study links this to hierarchical culture and the historical culture of silence, where seeking help can be seen as a sign of weakness or may be perceived as a risk of being viewed unfavourably by superiors. Help-seeking may be interpreted as not being macho enough.”

That helps explain why the existing support network has not translated into widespread use.

Ramacake and Lawakeli point out that existing supports include Police Psychology Unit programmes, chaplains, counsellors, Force medical officers, and the 2022 Mental Health Awareness Programme.

But the figures they cite tell a different story: only 46 per cent accessed counselling over 2018–2019, and 17 per cent in 2019–2020 (Annual Report), while 55 per cent of officers surveyed said they had never sought help for trauma-related issues.

“Operational debriefs are currently available to officers involved in fatal accidents or homicide; however, the approach is purely operational and does not initiate psychological therapy or holistic wellbeing.”

Building trust and support

The authors argue for something more consistent and more human: a professional debriefing system across all functional units should be embedded in Fijian cultural frameworks, Talanoa, and community- and family-oriented processes, rather than relying solely on clinical, Western formats.

“This should be led by trusted internal figures (chaplains, elders, peer leaders) alongside psychologists and counsellors, reflecting the value placed on elders’ guidance and communal responsibility (solesolevaki – working together, veivukei – mutual help) to
support the workforce.”

In the authors’ framing, that is not a softer option; it is a more credible one. Talanoa, with its open and relational style, can lower the threshold for disclosure in a hierarchical institution where formal interviews may feel accusatory and private pain may be kept private for too long.

The statistics for stigma are perhaps the most forceful sign that the problem is not cosmetic. That is not a marginal concern. It means a majority of respondents believed help-seeking still carried a social cost.

In a police culture shaped by discipline, rank and toughness, stigma does not just discourage conversation but can affect confidence and breed distrust. It governs behaviour. Officers may keep showing up, keep functioning, and keep absorbing pressure long after it has become harmful.

Ramacake and Lawakeli also distinguish between trauma from the job and trauma from inside the organisation. Operational trauma comes from the work itself: suicide scenes, assaults, domestic violence and other high-stress incidents.

Organisational trauma comes from bullying, discrimination, stand-over tactics, job insecurity and a lack of visible support. Their point is that these are not separate problems. The second compounds the first. When an institution cannot prioritise the wellbeing of its own people from internal stress, it makes recovery from external trauma harder.

The authors do not present the Force as negative static. They acknowledge progress in the development and dissemination of wellbeing policy and note that newer initiatives, such as awareness programmes and the Women’s Empowerment Programme,
are positive steps in the right direction.

But their own answers show that institutional intent is not the same as institutional effect. A policy can be formally adopted, publicly announced, and still fail to change behaviour where it matters most: in the ranks, at the station, after the incident, at the point of decision to ask for help or to stay silent.

That is why they place such emphasis on supervision. “Supervision serves three main functions: administrative, supportive, and educative. Through these three functions, a supervisor’s goal is to help officers carry out their role professionally and to a high standard, while also ensuring their wellbeing and self-care are not overlooked,” the authors said.

In practical terms, a key part of this is “unpacking” cases with officers, which gives them space to offload the stress and challenges of the job. This helps ensure they don’t carry that weight home with them – whether mentally, emotionally, or physically.

Ramacake and Lawakeli are also realistic about the limits of their study.

“This is a descriptive, cross-sectional survey (self-report, English-only, single time point),” they note, which means it is strong for showing patterns and cultural framing, but not for proving causality or testing what intervention works best.

“One thing is certain from this study: the stigma, trauma, and stress police officers face daily are real and damaging, and this can no longer be met with silence.

“Supporting officers’ wellbeing must be an urgent priority by seeing the implementation of more positive practice changes.”