EARLY in March 2024, two crew of a Spanish longliner at the door of the Fiji-based Human Dignity Group
(HDG) after three months at sea.
As the men told their story, much of it was not new to the HDG investigators. The master of one of the vessels had declared “no contracts for Fijians” and one of the crew had an insensitive leg. A 60kg swordfish fell on his leg when he slipped on the blast freezer floor.
But then came something the investigators had not heard previously from fishing vessel crew. The men had been hired in November 2023 to work as deckhands on a Spanish longline vessel when it berthed in the Port of Suva.
North of New Zealand, the men (and two other Fijian crew) had been transferred to another Spanish vessel and stayed aboard until it returned to Suva. During their time at sea, the vessel landed 70–100 tonnes of shark, a lot of swordfish, three tuna, and one wahoo – not the usual experience in warmer waters.
The sharks caught were identified by experts as shortfin mako (Isurus oxyrinchus) and blue sharks (Prionace glauca). These revelations prompted HDG to follow up on the men’s story.
Investigations found that each of six Spanish longliners— Carmen Tere (IMO 9098608), Playa Zahara (9297656), Playa Zahara Dos (9245976), Viking Bay (9221516), Glacial (9372157), Yanque (9297993)—entered Suva regularly. All of their harvests are offloaded and then either re-loaded onto freezer containers or retained at a large processing facility for later shipment.
Flagged to Spain, these vessels are under the European Union (EU) mantle, and the EU is a member of the Western and Central Pacific Fisheries Commission (WCPFC). The Commission manages fishing activity in areas beyond the 200 nautical mile Economic Exclusion Zones (EEZs) of Pacific member countries.
The WCPFC also addresses conservation issues and adopts Conservation and Management Measures (CMMs), which are agreed to and followed by member States. Under CMM 2024-05, fishing boats are prohibited from catching sharks on the high seas and exclusive economic zones of the Convention Area when they are listed on the 1982 Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of
Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES).
The blue shark caught by the Spanish boats is listed as near threatened, and the shortfin mako is endangered. Yet Spanish boats have landed their illegal catch in Fiji ports without hindrance. During the three-month voyage, all of the sharks were caught with illegal wire traces on abbreviated branch lines set close to the sea surface. Crew said the vessel Master had ordered the wire trace to be stored as the vessel approached Suva.
CMM 2024-05 states that from January 2024, “longline vessels targeting tuna and billfish do not use, or if carrying, must stow wire trace as branch lines or leaders and do not use shark lines or branch lines running directly off of the longline floats or drop lines between 20 degrees North and 20 degrees
South.”
By oversight—perhaps deliberate or omission—such fishing technique is permitted south of 20 S and north of 20 N, which are not the full Convention Area. And a cursory look at the global distribution of these two shark species reveals that they inhabit waters south of 20 deg South. But the WCPFC holds that CMM2024-05 applies to “the high seas and exclusive economic zones of the Convention Area’’.
Based on Global Fishing Watch satellite data, in mid-2025, the Glacial, Carmen Tere, Viking Bay fished north of 20 deg S in Fiji waters – such as north of Kadavu (at 19 deg S) and out of Suva (18 deg S). The landings from one of the vessels at Suva in May 2025 comprised 13 tonnes of shortfin mako, and more than 28 tonnes of blue shark – together comprising 66% of the total catch which included almost 19 tonnes of swordfish.
These amounts of retained shark cannot, in any stretch of imagination, be classed as ‘by-catch’. How these sharks were allowed to be landed in Suva raises questions – because Fiji’s Offshore Fisheries Management Decree is specific in stating that persons may not “…land, sell or offer… for sale, deal in, transport, receive or possess any endangered or protected fish,” all of which are referenced in
CITES Appendices I and II.
At the WCPFC’s Standing Committee in 2023, Spain stated: ‘‘The main catches are swordfish and blue shark. … . [The vessels] usually deploy wire leaders, since bycatches of blue shark and shortfin mako are significant for this fleet.’’ Spain further stated that blue shark was one of its primary target species. Spanish-flagged vessels took 681 tonnes of shortfin mako and 10,627 tonnes of blue shark from Pacific
waters south of the Equator in 2023–24.
Whether these tonnages were of complete or dressed weights is not stated. The WCPFC’s CMM2024-05 directs that vessels must retain “all parts of the shark excepting head, guts, vertebrae, and skins, to the point of first landing or transshipment,” with “fins naturally attached to the carcass,” and that “the practice of finning is prohibited”. But video and verbal evidence show that this does not appear to apply consistently on the Spanish vessels where fins are often removed.
All Spanish longliners operating in the WCPFC Convention Area are permitted to target ‘SWO [swordfish] and Related Species’ – which is strange, because all biologists know that sharks are very far away from being related to swordfish, which are closer to marlin and tuna.