A vindication: Will renewable energy bring justice?

August 30, 2025 • Web Admin •
Share this story:
A vindication: Will renewable energy bring justice?

THE International Court of Justice’s (ICJ) landmark advisory opinion on climate change has been hailed as a watershed moment for Small Island Developing States.

In a historic first, the world’s top court affirmed that states have legal obligations to protect vulnerable countries from the adverse effects of climate change, but for a low-lying atoll nation like Tuvalu, where half of Funafuti’s coastline has vanished in a generation, the question isn’t about legalese – it’s about survival.

“We won the moral argument, but we need solar panels, not just sympathy,’’ said Katalina Taho, a Tongan climate negotiator.

Across the Pacific, the question for leaders is: can a concerted effort to shift to renewable energy sources turn this legal victory into tangible justice?

Jubilation aside, the litmus test will be how the Pacific now leverages this decision to secure much-needed help in the push to achieve renewable energy targets.

At the 77th session of the United Nations General Assembly in March 2023, a resolution was adopted requesting that an advisory opinion be handed down by the ICJ on the obligations of States with respect to climate change.

Vanuatu played a leading role in the successful negotiations and consultations with other states for an opinion.

“An existential threat” is how climate change is described in the July 2025 opinion. States are therefore obligated to protect the climate system in line with other treaties like the Kyoto Protocol, Paris Agreement, environmental treaties, and international human rights law.

While emphasizing the duty of States with respect to climate change, specific obligations under international law to prevent and redress its adverse effects were not clearly spelled out. The opinion, however, gives Pacific and other Small Island Developing States legal precedent to wield at COP30 in Brazil and beyond.

The ruling has positive implications for Pacific Island countries, particularly with respect to nations meeting renewable energy targets. They can now cite this opinion to make a stronger case for increased funding assistance from bigger nations.

Renewables already contribute to energy needs in the Pacific, and countries have set ambitious but tangible targets for the role that they envision renewable energy will play moving forward.

The COP28 summit in 2023 saw a commitment made to triple renewable energy sources by 2030. In Small Island Developing States, sourcing of energy from renewable sources rose to 7.6GW in 2022, with the goal of reaching 30GW by 2030.

Most countries in the region have a renewable energy policy, but securing the necessary funding to implement these policies remains a major constraint. As of 2021, 40 renewable energy projects were being developed across the region in partnership with the World Bank. These projects are expected
to add an additional 420 megawatts of renewable energy generation.

At this stage, World Bank data indicate that 46% of electricity is generated from renewable sources.

Fiji, PNG, and Samoa have significant hydropower schemes contributing to this, while Vanuatu and Samoa use wind and solar in great capacity, respectively.

There are other renewable energy sources like geothermal and biomass, but they are not contributors on the scale of hydro and solar.

For the Pacific, the ICJ opinion makes stronger their arguments for climate change mitigation funding and the shift to clean energy. Many Pacific Island countries contribute less than 0.03% of global emissions yet face existential threats.

The opinion makes it clear that high-emitting nations must assist in financing and technology transfers to help smaller, more vulnerable nations adapt and decarbonise.

Fiji spends about 22.98% of its GDP on fuel imports. Vanuatu and Solomon Islands have electricity costs up to four times higher than the global average, due to their heavy reliance on imported diesel for electricity generation.

Renewable energy—particularly solar, wind, and hydropower—can drastically cut these costs while reducing emissions. There is now a strong case to be made to potential donors to do their bit to help.

As Pacific negotiators prepare for COP30, the message is clear: the ICJ’s opinion must translate to wind turbines microgrids, and ocean-powered desalination plants – tangible justice.

The courts have spoken. Now, the world must listen.