DIFFERENCES between the French State and the independence movement were again highlighted last month over the status of Umaenupne (Matthew) and Umaeneag (Hunter) – two uninhabited volcanic islands located to the east of New Caledonia and south-east of Vanuatu.
Both islands are disputed territory, claimed by the Republic of Vanuatu and also France as the administering colonial power in New Caledonia.
As the New Caledonian delegation landed in Port Vila last month, FLNKS President Christian Tein reaffirmed the longstanding position of the independence coalition: That despite ongoing talks to resolve the disputed maritime boundary, Matthew and Hunter belong to Vanuatu.
This policy was formalised in July 2009, as delegations from the Vanuatu Government and the FLNKS met on the island of Tanna in Vanuatu’s Tafea Province.
Together with customary leaders from the two national councils of chiefs—Vanuatu’s Malvatumauri and New Caledonia’s Senat coutumier—they signed the Keamu Accord, described as “a solemn commitment between the Kanak people and the people of Vanuatu, that whatever the political and institutional future of New Caledonia, Matthew and
Hunter Islands will always remain the property of the people of Vanuatu.”
At the time, this act of Oceanic diplomacy between Melanesian peoples sparked anger amongst anti-independence politicians in Noumea, as well as rebukes from French officials who saw the Keamu Accord undercutting France’s negotiating position over the status of the islands.
In February 2018, delegations from France and Vanuatu met in Sydney for the first round of talks to resolve the outstanding dispute, with a second round held in Brussels in June 2019.
Further negotiations were delayed during the COVID-19 pandemic, and it was only in November last year that Vanuatu and France resumed formal talks on sovereignty.
For Mickaël Forrest, Christian Tein’s recent statement on the islands was simply a reaffirmation of the cultural understanding between customary leaders in the two Melanesian nations: the FLNKS has long stated that—unlike the peoples of Vanuatu’s southern islands—chiefs and clans from New Caledonia’s Loyalty Islands have no historic, cultural ties to Matthew and Hunter.
“All we did was to recall the historic connections, because these islands are part of the cultural heritage of Melanesian peoples,” Forrest told Islands Business.
“In New Caledonia, both the FLNKS and the Kanak Customary Senate have defended this position on Matthew and Hunter. This is nothing new, and has been repeatedly stated by leaders such as Rock Wamytan, Victor Tutugoro and Madame Caroline Machoro.”
For Forrest, it’s both natural and logical if the current FLNKS president, Tein, says the same thing – the status of these two islands is a matter between Melanesian peoples.
“We’re aware that in the colonial context, there are discussions underway about these islands,” Forrest said.
“But even if it raises concern amongst some observers, there’s no problem on our part to repeat our longstanding position. For Kanak, for the FLNKS, for the Senat coutumier, Matthew and Hunter are part of the Republic of Vanuatu’s natural heritage – full stop.”